Giving Thanks

Podcast available on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or your favourite streaming platform!

Gratitude Is a Feeling. Thanksgiving Is a Practice. The actual practice of giving thanks!

Imagine spending weeks searching for the perfect gift for someone you love. You think about their interests, save up for it, wrap it carefully, and wait in anticipation for the moment they open it. When they finally do, their face lights up. They smile, maybe even tear up a little, and you can tell they genuinely appreciate what you've given them. They're grateful.

But what if they never actually said, "Thank you"?

What if they simply set the gift aside and moved on with the rest of the day without ever acknowledging your generosity? You might assume they appreciated it, but something would still feel incomplete. Gratitude may have been present in their heart, but thanksgiving was absent from their response.

This Thanksgiving, I've been reflecting on the subtle but significant difference between those two words. We often use gratitude and thanksgiving interchangeably, but Scripture reveals a meaningful distinction. Gratitude is an inward posture. Thanksgiving is its outward expression. Gratitude is what we feel; thanksgiving is what we do.

That distinction matters because our faith has never been content with merely transforming our thoughts. God is after our hearts, certainly, but he is also interested in the habits that shape them. Throughout Scripture, he repeatedly invites his people not simply to feel grateful but to give thanks. Again and again, thanksgiving is described not as a fleeting emotion but as a deliberate practice that forms the life of a follower of Jesus.

Paul writes, "Rejoice always, pray continually, give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God's will for you in Christ Jesus" (1 Thessalonians 5:16–18).

I've often found that phrase, "this is God's will," intimidating. We tend to associate God's will with life's major decisions: Which career should I pursue? Should I move? Who should I marry? Yet here, God's will is remarkably ordinary. It is found in rejoicing, praying, and giving thanks. Apparently, one of the clearest ways we align ourselves with God's design is by becoming people who consistently express gratitude.

Notice that Paul doesn't tell us to feel thankful in all circumstances. Emotions are not something we can simply switch on. They ebb and flow with our circumstances. Instead, he calls us to practice thanksgiving regardless of our circumstances. Thanksgiving is an act of trust before it is an emotional response.

Our culture often encourages passive appreciation. A quick "like" on social media acknowledges someone's accomplishment without requiring much of us. It's effortless. A thoughtful comment, a handwritten note, or a personal conversation, however, communicates something much deeper. One recognizes another person's gift; the other honours the giver.

I wonder if we sometimes approach God in much the same way.

We appreciate his blessings. We enjoy the gifts he places in our lives. Yet how often do we intentionally return to acknowledge the Giver?

For followers of Jesus, gratitude begins in a place far deeper than favourable circumstances. It begins with grace.

Our natural tendency is to measure God's goodness by the quality of our lives. If life is going well, we assume we have much to be thankful for. If life is difficult, gratitude becomes harder to access. But the gospel offers us a different foundation altogether. Our greatest reason for thanksgiving has never been our circumstances. It has always been the cross.

One of the most beautiful words in our faith is atonement. Though it may sound technical, its meaning is wonderfully personal. Through his death and resurrection, Jesus accomplished what we never could. He took upon himself the consequence of our sin, removed the barrier that separated us from God, and made reconciliation possible. The relationship that had been fractured by sin was restored by grace.

That reality changes everything.

Paul writes in Romans 8:32, "He who did not spare his own Son, but gave him up for us all—how will he not also, along with him, graciously give us all things?"

We spend much of our lives convinced that what we need most is just beyond our reach. A little more money. A better job. A healthier body. More influence. More freedom. More certainty about the future. The list is endless because our hearts are remarkably skilled at focusing on what is absent.

Grace redirects our attention.

The cross reminds us that God has already given us the most valuable gift imaginable. If he has not withheld his own Son, then every other blessing we receive is evidence of his continuing generosity. Gratitude grows when we stop measuring our lives by what we lack and begin remembering what we have already received.

Jesus illustrates this beautifully in the account of the ten lepers in Luke 17.

To modern readers, leprosy often sounds like simply another disease. In the ancient world, however, it was devastating. Beyond the physical suffering, those diagnosed with leprosy were isolated from their families, excluded from their communities, and considered ceremonially unclean according to Jewish law. They lived on the margins of society, unable to participate fully in worship or everyday life. Healing didn't simply mean healthier skin. It meant restoration to family, community, worship, and hope.

When these ten men encountered Jesus, they cried out for mercy. Jesus instructed them to go show themselves to the priests, and as they obeyed, they were healed.

Imagine the joy they must have felt. After perhaps years of isolation, they could finally return home. They could embrace loved ones again. They could worship alongside their community once more. Their entire future had changed in a single encounter with Jesus.

Yet only one returned.

Luke tells us that he came back praising God with a loud voice before falling at Jesus' feet in thanksgiving. Jesus then asked a haunting question: "Were not all ten cleansed? Where are the other nine?"

I've always wondered what happened to the others.

Perhaps they intended to come back later. Perhaps they were simply overwhelmed. Perhaps they became so captivated by the gift that they forgot the Giver.

If I'm honest, I recognize myself in those nine far more often than I would like to admit.

How many prayers have I prayed with urgency, only to move quickly to my next request once God answered the first? How often have I thanked God internally without ever slowing down long enough to express it? How frequently have I enjoyed his blessings while overlooking the One from whom every blessing comes?

Gratitude notices the gift. Thanksgiving returns to the Giver.

Interestingly, the wisdom of Scripture is increasingly being affirmed by modern neuroscience. Researchers have found that practicing gratitude changes the brain over time. Regular expressions of thanksgiving strengthen neural pathways associated with positive emotion and help shift our attention away from fear, scarcity, and anxiety. While gratitude doesn't eliminate hardship, it changes the way we interpret it.

Long before brain scans existed, Paul understood this truth. In Philippians 4, he encourages believers to bring every anxiety before God "by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving." Thanksgiving isn't an afterthought to prayer; it's part of the pathway to peace. Rather than simply unloading our worries before God, thanksgiving reminds us of his faithfulness while we wait for him to act again.

This doesn't mean pretending life is easier than it is. Our faith does not call us to denial. Gratitude is not ignoring pain. It acknowledges hardship while refusing to let hardship become the loudest voice in the room. It remembers that even when circumstances remain uncertain, God's character does not.

Perhaps that is why Scripture repeatedly commands thanksgiving. Not because God needs our affirmation, but because we need the perspective it cultivates.

The more we practice thanksgiving, the more we begin to see life as gift rather than entitlement. Homework becomes evidence that we have access to an education. Chores remind us that we have a home to care for. Friendships become reasons for celebration rather than comparison. Even ordinary moments become opportunities to recognize God's generosity woven throughout the day.

Thanksgiving, then, is not merely a holiday we celebrate once each October. It is a way of inhabiting the world. It is the daily practice of remembering that everything we have—and ultimately everything we are—has been received by grace.

This Thanksgiving, I hope we do more than feel grateful. I hope we become people who intentionally give thanks. Not because life is perfect, but because God is faithful. Not because every prayer has been answered exactly as we hoped, but because the greatest gift has already been given.

The cross forever reminds us that God's generosity is not measured by the ease of our circumstances but by the depth of his love. And if that is true, then no matter what season we find ourselves in, we will always have a reason to return to the Giver and simply say, "Thank You."

What’s in the Ears

This is the part where I share a song or podcast I’m currently into. This song by Maverick City Music is titled God I’m Just Grateful and it’s is pretty well suited for Thanksgiving. Let me know if you check it out! 

If this stirred something in you, share this post with a friend or drop a comment below. I’d love to hear what small step you’re taking towards the flourishing life today! And don’t forget to subscribe so you don’t miss a thing.